Nature's Sunshine (NATR): Should You Buy, Sell, or Hold After Q3 Results?

Nature's Sunshine: Recent Performance and Investor Considerations

Nature's Sunshine has experienced a remarkable surge in its stock price, climbing 66.9% over the past half year to reach $27.54 per share. This impressive growth was fueled in part by strong quarterly earnings, prompting investors to reassess their strategies regarding the stock.

Is this a good moment to add Nature's Sunshine to your holdings, or is caution warranted before making a move?

Why We Remain Cautious About Nature's Sunshine

While shareholders have benefited from the recent price appreciation, we believe there are more attractive investment options than Nature's Sunshine. Here are three reasons we prefer other opportunities over NATR, along with a stock we favor instead.

1. Weak Long-Term Sales Expansion

Consistent revenue growth is a hallmark of high-quality businesses. Although any company can enjoy short-term gains, the best performers deliver steady increases year after year. Nature's Sunshine, however, has posted only a 2.8% compound annual revenue growth rate over the past three years, which falls short of our expectations.

Nature's Sunshine Quarterly Revenue

2. Limited Distribution Restricts Potential

Generating $474.5 million in sales over the last year, Nature's Sunshine is a relatively small player in the consumer staples sector. This size disadvantage can make it harder to compete with larger rivals who benefit from greater scale and stronger bargaining power with retailers.

3. Modest Growth Outlook

Analyst forecasts provide insight into a company’s future prospects. While projections are not always precise, accelerating growth tends to lift valuations and share prices, whereas slowdowns can have the opposite effect.

For the coming year, Wall Street expects Nature's Sunshine’s revenue to increase by just 3.1%. This muted outlook suggests that new product launches are unlikely to drive significant top-line improvements in the near term.

Our Verdict

Although Nature's Sunshine is not a poor business, it does not meet our investment criteria. Following its recent rally, the stock is valued at 29.2 times forward earnings (or $27.54 per share), indicating that much optimism is already reflected in the price. We believe there are more compelling choices available. Consider exploring our top semiconductor sector pick instead.

Top-Tier Stocks for Any Market Environment

Building a successful portfolio requires looking beyond yesterday’s winners. Concentrating on overcrowded stocks increases risk as market dynamics shift.

The next generation of high-growth companies can be found in our Top 6 Stocks for this week. This handpicked selection of High Quality stocks has delivered a remarkable 244% return over the past five years (as of June 30, 2025).

Our list features well-known leaders like Nvidia, which soared 1,326% from June 2020 to June 2025, as well as lesser-known success stories such as Kadant, which achieved a 351% five-year gain. Discover your next standout investment with StockStory today.