Spotting Top Performers: Papa John's (NASDAQ:PZZA) Versus Classic Fast Food Shares In The Fourth Quarter

Q4 Fast Food Earnings: Winners and Losers

As earnings season wraps up, it’s the perfect opportunity to review which fast food giants excelled and which lagged behind in the fourth quarter. Here’s a breakdown of how major players in the traditional fast food sector performed, starting with Papa John’s (NASDAQ: PZZA).

Overview of Traditional Fast Food Chains

Classic fast food restaurants are celebrated for their quick service and accessible prices, offering familiar menu items that appeal to busy individuals and families. While these chains remain popular for their convenience, they continue to face criticism regarding the nutritional value and quality of their food—a challenge that’s even more pressing as consumers become increasingly health-conscious.

Q4 Performance Snapshot

Among the 11 traditional fast food companies we monitor, the group collectively delivered a robust fourth quarter, with revenue surpassing Wall Street expectations by 1.2%.

Despite these positive results, share prices for these companies have remained largely stable, with little movement since the latest earnings announcements.

Papa John’s (NASDAQ: PZZA)

Papa John’s, founded by John “Papa John” Schnatter, has built a global reputation for its pizza delivery and carryout services, promoting the use of superior ingredients and a commitment to quality pizza.

For the quarter, Papa John’s generated $498.2 million in revenue, marking a 6.1% decrease compared to the previous year. This figure was 3.8% below analyst projections. The company experienced a challenging period, missing both revenue and full-year EBITDA forecasts.

Papa John’s posted the weakest revenue growth among its peers. Following the earnings release, its stock price has dropped 8.2% and is currently trading at $31.05.

Top Performer: Krispy Kreme (NASDAQ: DNUT)

Krispy Kreme, famous for its Original Glazed doughnuts and as the parent company of Insomnia Cookies, stands out as one of the world’s most cherished fast food brands.

In Q4, Krispy Kreme reported $392.4 million in revenue, a 2.9% year-over-year decline, but still managed to exceed analyst expectations by 1%. The company delivered a strong quarter, beating both EPS and EBITDA forecasts.

Krispy Kreme Total Revenue

Investors responded positively, with the stock climbing 21.9% since the earnings announcement. Shares are now valued at $3.65.

Biggest Miss: Jack in the Box (NASDAQ: JACK)

Since 1951, Jack in the Box has attracted customers with its inventive menu and playful marketing, setting itself apart in the fast food landscape.

Jack in the Box posted $349.5 million in revenue for the quarter, a 5.8% decrease from the previous year and 4.8% below analyst expectations. The company missed both revenue and same-store sales forecasts, resulting in a softer quarter.

Jack in the Box had the largest shortfall relative to analyst estimates among its peers. The stock has declined 31.5% since the earnings release and is now trading at $15.09.

Wendy’s (NASDAQ: WEN)

Founded by Dave Thomas in 1969, Wendy’s is renowned for its fresh, never-frozen beef and a menu focused on quality and flavor.

Wendy’s reported $543 million in revenue, a 5.5% drop year over year, but still managed to beat analyst estimates by 1.3%. Despite this, the company missed both full-year EBITDA and same-store sales targets.

The stock price has remained steady since the earnings report and is currently at $7.29.

Domino’s (NASDAQ: DPZ)

Launched by two brothers in Michigan, Domino’s has become a global leader in pizza delivery, known for its innovative marketing and speedy service.

Domino’s saw revenues rise to $1.54 billion, a 6.4% increase from the prior year, surpassing analyst forecasts by 1.2%. The quarter was generally positive, with revenue beating expectations, though EPS fell short.

Shares have risen 5.6% since the earnings release and are now priced at $406.00.

Market Outlook

Following the Federal Reserve’s interest rate hikes in 2022 and 2023, inflation has steadily declined from its post-pandemic peak, moving closer to the Fed’s 2% goal. Despite increased borrowing costs, the economy has avoided recession, achieving the “soft landing” many investors hoped for. Recent rate reductions (0.5% in September and 0.25% in November 2024) have further boosted equities, making 2024 a strong year for stocks. Donald Trump’s presidential victory in November spurred additional market gains, with indices reaching new highs. However, ongoing debates about tariffs and corporate taxes have introduced uncertainty about economic conditions in 2025.

If you’re looking to invest in companies with strong fundamentals, explore our 9 Best Market-Beating Stocks—these businesses are well-positioned for growth regardless of the broader economic or political environment.

About StockStory: Our team of experienced analysts leverages data-driven methods and automation to deliver timely, high-quality market insights that help you stay ahead.