Insurance Brokers Q4 Summary: Arthur J. Gallagher (NYSE:AJG)

Q4 Earnings Recap: Insurance Brokerage Sector

As the latest earnings season winds down, let's review some of the standout—and less impressive—performances from the fourth quarter among insurance brokerage companies. We begin with Arthur J. Gallagher (NYSE:AJG).

Industry Overview

The insurance brokerage sector is shaped by trends in insurance pricing but also benefits from ongoing structural growth. Increasingly complex risks—such as those related to climate change and data privacy—along with tighter regulations and rising insurance costs, are driving greater demand for expert risk management advice. Brokers typically earn commissions and fees based on premium volumes, and are seeing a growing share of income from recurring services like consulting, benefits, and compliance. Larger firms enjoy significant advantages, including better access to insurance carriers, superior data and benchmarking capabilities, and more efficient use of technology and compliance resources, all of which support continued industry consolidation. However, the sector faces challenges such as high labor demands, wage inflation, regulatory hurdles, and the difficulties of integrating new digital tools into established processes.

Q4 Performance Snapshot

Among the five insurance brokers we track, the fourth quarter was generally subdued. Collectively, their revenues came in 1.1% below what analysts had forecasted.

Stock prices have reflected this softness, with the group seeing an average decline of 6.4% since their earnings announcements.

Arthur J. Gallagher (NYSE:AJG)

Founded in 1927, Arthur J. Gallagher operates in about 130 countries, offering insurance brokerage, reinsurance, consulting, and third-party claims management services to clients worldwide.

For Q4, Arthur J. Gallagher posted revenues of $3.61 billion, marking a 34.8% increase year over year. This result matched analyst expectations, and the company narrowly surpassed EPS estimates, making for a mixed quarter overall.

“We had an excellent fourth quarter and a terrific 2025!” commented J. Patrick Gallagher, Jr., Chairman and CEO.

Despite these results, the stock has dropped 14% since the report and is currently trading at $211.48.

Top Q4 Performer: Marsh & McLennan (NYSE:MRSH)

Tracing its origins to 1871 and operating in over 130 countries, Marsh & McLennan is a global professional services firm that helps organizations navigate risk, strategy, and workforce issues through its four specialized divisions.

In the fourth quarter, Marsh & McLennan reported $6.60 billion in revenue, an 8.7% year-over-year increase that exceeded analyst forecasts by 0.7%. The company also outperformed on both EPS and organic revenue estimates.

Marsh & McLennan delivered the strongest beat versus analyst expectations among its peers. However, the market response was muted, with shares down 1.3% since the results, now trading at $175.81.

Q4 Laggard: Ryan Specialty (NYSE:RYAN)

Established in 2010 by industry veteran Patrick Ryan, Ryan Specialty is a wholesale insurance broker and underwriting manager that assists retail brokers in placing complex or hard-to-insure risks.

Ryan Specialty reported Q4 revenues of $751.2 million, up 13.2% year over year but falling short of analyst expectations by 2.6%. The company missed both revenue and EPS estimates by a significant margin.

Ryan Specialty had the weakest performance relative to analyst forecasts among its peers. As a result, its stock has declined 16.3% since the earnings release and is currently priced at $37.12.

Baldwin Insurance Group (NASDAQ:BWIN)

Formerly known as BRP Group until May 2024, Baldwin Insurance Group is an independent insurance distributor offering customized insurance, risk management, and employee benefits solutions to both businesses and individuals.

For the fourth quarter, Baldwin Insurance Group reported $347.3 million in revenue, a 5.3% increase year over year, but this was 1.4% below analyst expectations. The company also missed both revenue and organic revenue estimates.

Baldwin Insurance Group recorded the slowest revenue growth among its peers. Despite this, the stock has risen 12.8% since the earnings report and is now trading at $20.87.

Brown & Brown (NYSE:BRO)

Founded in 1939, Brown & Brown operates across 44 U.S. states and 14 countries, providing insurance brokerage and risk management services in property, casualty, and employee benefits.

Brown & Brown reported Q4 revenues of $1.61 billion, up 35.7% from the previous year but 2.2% below analyst expectations. The company also missed both revenue and organic revenue estimates by a notable margin.

Despite achieving the fastest revenue growth among its peers, Brown & Brown’s stock has fallen 13.2% since the earnings release and is currently valued at $69.13.

Looking for High-Quality Investments?

If you’re seeking companies with strong fundamentals, explore our Top 5 Quality Compounder Stocks. These businesses are well-positioned for growth, regardless of political or economic shifts.

The StockStory analyst team—comprised of experienced professional investors—leverages quantitative analysis and automation to deliver timely, high-quality market insights.