are utility stocks good during a recession

This article examines whether utility stocks are good during a recession, explaining why utilities are considered defensive, reviewing historical performance, outlining the risks (especially intere...

2025-12-25 16:00:00

By ChainSync Analyst

Article rating

4.6

117 ratings

Bitget offers a variety of ways to buy or sell popular cryptocurrencies. Buy now!

A welcome pack worth 6200 USDT for new users! Sign up now!

Utility stocks during recessions

Are utility stocks good during a recession? This article answers that question directly and in depth. It explains what utility stocks are, why investors treat them as defensive holdings, how they have behaved in past recessions, which macro and company factors change their performance, and practical criteria and portfolio strategies for using utilities when economic growth slows. Readers will finish with a clear checklist to evaluate specific utility names or ETFs and guidance on how utility exposure compares with bonds and other defensive assets.

Note: This article focuses on U.S. and global equity markets and utility-sector equities (electric, gas, water, transmission, regulated and some non‑regulated affiliates). It is not investment advice and does not recommend buying or selling any specific security or trading venue.

Definition and scope

Utility stocks are shares of companies that provide essential services: electricity generation and distribution, natural gas distribution, water supply and sewage, and related transmission or infrastructure services.

Typical investor objectives when buying utility stocks include income (dividends), defensive exposure (lower volatility than cyclicals), and exposure to regulated cash flows. Utility companies often have large capital programs, stable customer bases, and a regulatory framework that shapes revenues and allowed returns.

This article uses "utility stocks" to mean listed equities in these sectors, including traditional regulated utilities, merchant power generators, and utility infrastructure owners. It also discusses sector ETFs and dividend‑focused strategies.

Why utilities are considered defensive

In conversations about recession resilience, a common question is: are utility stocks good during a recession? Utilities are widely labeled defensive for several core reasons.

Essential services sustain demand. Households and businesses continue to require electricity, gas, and water even in downturns.
Regulated or contracted revenue. Many utilities recover costs and earn allowed returns under regulatory rate‑setting, which can smooth income.
Predictable cash flows. Long‑term customer bases and recurring billing create stable cash generation.
Dividend income. Utilities historically pay above‑market dividend yields, attractive to income‑seeking investors.

These characteristics make utility stocks appealing when growth slows, but they do not make utilities invulnerable. The next sections unpack why utilities are defensive and what can still harm them.

Demand stability and essential nature

Electricity, natural gas, and water are essential for daily life and most commercial activity. During recessions, consumption patterns can shift (less industrial demand, stable or slightly down residential demand), but baseline usage persists.

Because of this, revenue declines during recessions are often smaller for utilities than for discretionary sectors. That resilience is a primary reason many investors ask: are utility stocks good during a recession?

Regulatory frameworks and rate‑setting

A major stabilizer for many utility companies is regulation. In regulated jurisdictions, utilities operate as monopolies for a territory but must file rate cases with regulators (public utility commissions) to recover costs and earn an allowed return on their rate base.

Regulatory mechanisms vary by country and state. Typical features that support recession resilience include:

Cost recovery clauses for fuel or purchased power.
Pass‑through mechanisms for certain expenses.
Allowed return on equity (ROE) that provides predictable profitability bands.

These frameworks do not eliminate risk, but they reduce earnings volatility compared with unregulated businesses.

Dividend income and payout behavior

Investors often buy utilities for yield. Utilities tend to trade at higher dividend yields than the broad market because of their steady cash flows and investor demand for income.

Dividend behavior matters: many large regulated utilities strive to maintain or grow dividends to preserve investor confidence. During recessions, dividends can cushion total returns compared with sectors that cut payouts or pay none.

However, payout safety varies by company. Dividend sustainability depends on cash flow coverage, regulatory support, and balance‑sheet health.

Historical performance in recessions

A central empirical question is: historically, are utility stocks good during a recession? The short answer is that utilities often outperform the broader market on a relative basis in downturns, but they still can and do decline in absolute terms during severe selloffs.

Relative vs absolute performance

Utilities typically experience smaller drawdowns than cyclical sectors during market stress. That means they can be "less bad" rather than "positive" in absolute terms. During systemic liquidity events or broad equity crashes, defensive sectors including utilities may fall as investors sell equities across the board. But over multi‑month recession periods, utilities often recover faster or decline less.

This relative strength is why many portfolio managers include utilities as a defensive ballast. Still, because utilities have high payout yields and capital intensity, their valuations can be sensitive to interest rates, which can create larger-than-expected declines when rates rise.

Representative data and ETF performance (e.g., XLU)

Sector ETFs provide a convenient way to observe historical performance. The utilities sector ETF commonly used by U.S. investors is the widely followed sector ETF for utilities (ticker commonly referenced in market coverage). Studies and sector performance tables show utilities often outperformed the S&P 500 during periods of economic contraction on a relative basis.

Academic and industry studies comparing sector returns during recessions find a consistent pattern: utilities are among the more defensive sectors but are not immune to prolonged market stress. For example, sector analyses included in industry reports and academic papers show utilities' volatility and drawdowns are generally lower than cyclicals but can still be significant when interest rates or credit spreads widen.

Factors that influence utility performance during recessions

Whether utility stocks are good during a recession depends on several macro and micro drivers. Key factors include interest rates, inflation and stagflation, credit conditions and leverage, regulatory decisions, and capital expenditure programs.

Interest‑rate sensitivity and valuation

Utilities pay higher dividends and often carry significant regulated or contractually supported assets. That makes them behave like long‑duration assets: their valuations are sensitive to interest‑rate moves.

When rates fall, present value calculations for utility cash flows increase, which supports utility valuations. Conversely, rising rates can pressure utility share prices even if underlying utility cash flows are stable.

In a recessionary environment accompanied by falling rates, utilities typically benefit. In a recession with rising rates or tightening credit (less common but possible during stagflation), utilities can underperform because higher rates raise borrowing costs and reduce equity valuations.

Inflation and stagflation effects

Inflation affects utilities in different ways. Some regulated frameworks allow cost pass‑throughs that protect margins. Others have lagged adjustment periods and can compress margins during sharp inflation.

Stagflation — stagnant growth with high inflation — is often more challenging for utilities if regulators do not immediately adjust allowed returns or rate bases. In such environments, utilities' high leverage and capital‑intensity can combine with higher operating costs to create stress.

Credit quality and capital structure

Utilities are capital‑intensive and frequently finance projects with long‑term debt. Credit quality matters: investment‑grade balance sheets with manageable debt/EBITDA and strong interest coverage are better positioned to withstand recessions and tighter capital markets.

Companies with weaker credit profiles can face higher borrowing costs or refinancing risks during downturns, which can amplify equity weakness.

Sub‑sectors and growth opportunities within utilities

Not all utility stocks behave the same in recessions. Sub‑sector differences matter for both defensive characteristics and growth prospects.

Traditional regulated utilities (electric, gas, water)

Regulated electric, gas distribution, and water utilities are the classic defensive utility holdings. Their regulated revenue mixes and stable customer bases make them low‑growth but steady income generators.

Investors seeking recession resilience often prefer high regulated‑revenue share names with stable payout histories and investment‑grade ratings.

Power generation, merchant/competitive utilities, and infrastructure owners

Merchant power generators and competitive utilities face more volume and price risk because they sell into competitive wholesale markets. Their earnings can be more cyclical and sensitive to demand and commodity prices.

Infrastructure owners (e.g., transmission, midstream where applicable) can provide a hybrid profile: stable contract revenues for certain assets, but exposure to project execution and capital markets.

Renewables, storage, and grid services (growth drivers)

Decarbonization and electrification create growth tailwinds. Utilities investing in grid upgrades, storage, and renewables can offer growth optionality that complements defensive income. In recessions, these growth projects may be subject to capital constraints, but longer‑term contracts and regulatory support can mitigate downside.

Innovations like demand from data centers (including AI workloads) have been cited by analysts as structural drivers that increase long‑term electricity demand. These drivers can differentiate winners over multi‑year horizons even if they add near‑term capital intensity.

Risks and drawbacks of owning utility stocks in recessions

While utility stocks can be conservative, they come with specific risks that matter in recessions.

Interest‑rate and duration sensitivity: Rising rates can compress valuations.
Regulatory and political risk: Rate decisions, policy shifts, and public backlash against bills or rate increases can damage revenue prospects.
Capital‑intensity and execution risk: Large infrastructure projects can suffer delays and cost overruns, which stress cash flow and credit.
Valuation traps: High yields can mask failing businesses or regulatory exposure.
Event‑specific shocks: Extreme weather, cyber incidents, or large outages can cause unexpected losses and regulatory scrutiny.

Understanding these risks is essential when assessing whether are utility stocks good during a recession for a given investor.

How to evaluate utility stocks for recession resilience

To assess whether a specific utility is a good recession holding, use both quantitative metrics and qualitative judgment.

Quantitative metrics

Key ratios and benchmarks to check:

Dividend payout ratio: Compare cash dividends to free cash flow. Lower payout ratios provide a cushion in stress.
Debt/EBITDA and debt/equity: Measure leverage against industry norms.
Interest coverage (EBITDA/interest expense): Higher coverage indicates resilience.
Regulated revenue share: Higher percentage of regulated revenue generally equals more predictable cash flows.
Allowed ROE and rate base growth: Higher allowed returns and steady rate base growth support earnings.

Suggested benchmarks vary, but investors often favor utilities with investment‑grade credit metrics, payout ratios below 80% of cash flow in stress scenarios, and debt/EBITDA levels consistent with peers.

Qualitative considerations

Regulatory environment: Is the state or country supportive of cost recovery and infrastructure investment?
Management track record: Has management executed large capex programs without large overruns?
Customer mix: Heavy industrial exposure adds cyclicality; residential focus is more defensive.
ESG and regulatory risks: Environmental or political pressures can change allowed returns or require costly upgrades.

Combining these elements answers whether a particular utility security is likely to remain stable during recessionary pressure.

Investment strategies for using utilities in a recessionary portfolio

When deciding how to use utilities during a recession, investors can take several approaches depending on objectives and risk tolerance.

Defensive ballast: Allocate a modest percentage to high‑quality utilities to reduce portfolio volatility and provide income.
Income generation: Use utilities for yield in taxable or income‑focused accounts, checking dividend sustainability.
Partial hedge vs bonds: Utilities can offer some income and defensive properties like bonds, but they are equities with equity risk.
ETFs vs individual stocks: Sector ETFs provide diversification and ease of trading; individual names allow selective exposure to balance sheets and regulatory regimes.

Allocation guidance and diversification

Position sizing should reflect risk tolerance and portfolio goals. Common practical steps:

Avoid overweighting utilities to the point of concentration risk.
Combine with other defensive sectors (consumer staples, healthcare) to diversify defensive exposure.
Rebalance periodically to avoid buying high and holding oversized positions after runups.

ETFs, mutual funds, and stock picks

ETFs and mutual funds focused on utilities or dividends can simplify exposure and reduce single‑company risk. For investors who prefer single names, focus on regulated utilities with strong balance sheets and transparent regulatory frameworks.

When discussing execution or trading the sector, consider a reputable trading venue. If you trade or rebalance portfolios, Bitget provides market access and tools for traders and investors. For web3 wallet needs, Bitget Wallet is recommended.

Special scenarios: stagflation, falling vs rising interest rates

Macro regimes change how utilities perform.

Falling interest rates: Utilities generally perform well as discount rates fall and dividend yields look more attractive versus bonds.
Rising rates: Utilities can underperform because yields look less attractive and borrowing costs rise.
Stagflation: Slow growth plus high inflation can be challenging unless regulation allows quick pass‑through of costs.

Evaluating the expected macro backdrop helps determine whether are utility stocks good during a recession in a specific period.

Alternatives and complements to utility exposure

Investors seeking recession resilience can also consider:

High‑quality government or corporate bonds and TIPS.
Consumer staples and healthcare equities with defensive demand.
Dividend aristocrats across sectors.
Cash equivalents and short‑term credit for liquidity.

Utilities provide a mix of income and defensiveness, but they are just one tool among many.

Case studies and recent market examples

To provide context and timeliness, note selected market commentary.

截至 2024-06-01，据 S&P Global 报道，分析师指出在经济放缓期间，一些公用事业公司受益于受监管的收入和长期资产基数的稳定性。该报道强调了监管机制在缓冲短期需求波动方面的作用。
截至 2023-09-15，据 Morningstar 报道，行业研究表明，公用事业作为防御性板块在多数经济收缩期间相对抗跌，但在利率快速上行期仍会面临估值压力。

These summaries reflect widely reported themes from sector studies. They underscore that while utilities often provide relative protection, macro drivers like rates and credit conditions materially influence outcomes.

Practical considerations and tax implications

Dividends from utility stocks are typically taxed as ordinary dividends or qualified dividends depending on holding period and the issuer. Investors in taxable accounts should consider dividend tax rates when favoring high‑yield utility stocks.

Holding utilities in tax‑advantaged accounts (retirement accounts) can be efficient for high‑yield names. Check local tax rules and consult a tax professional for specifics.

Summary and investor checklist

Answering the core question: are utility stocks good during a recession? Short answer: utilities are commonly good defensive holdings during recessions because of steady demand, regulated revenue, and dividends. However, they are not recession‑proof and are vulnerable to interest‑rate spikes, inflation without pass‑through, and credit stress.

Investor checklist before buying a utility for recession resilience:

Does the company have a high share of regulated or contracted revenue?
Is the dividend payout supported by free cash flow? (Check payout ratio.)
What is the credit rating / debt metrics (debt/EBITDA, interest coverage)?
How exposed is the company to interest rates and refinancing? What is its debt maturity schedule?
Are allowed ROE and rate‑base growth supportive of earnings?
Does the regulatory environment favor cost recovery for capex and operating expenses?
Is management track record solid on project execution and regulatory relations?
Are there event risks (large projects, weather exposure, cyber incidents)?

Use this checklist to determine whether are utility stocks good during a recession for your portfolio needs.

Practical next steps

If you are evaluating utility exposure for recession resilience:

Run the checklist above on prospective holdings or ETFs.
Compare utility yields and payout ratios with bond yields and credit spreads.
Consider using diversified utilities ETFs for broad exposure or select regulated names with strong credit for targeted holdings.
For trading and account execution, consider Bitget for market access and Bitget Wallet for custody if using web3 features.

Explore more Bitget resources to learn how to manage dividend‑focused or defensive equity allocations and for platform tools that support research and execution.

更多实用建议：关注公司公告和监管决策，监测利率与信用市场变化，保持仓位分散并按计划再平衡。

The content above has been sourced from the internet and generated using AI. For high-quality content, please visit Bitget Academy.